Packers fans rank NFC North quarterbacks in the question of the week

4 days ago 2

GREEN BAY – The Green Bay Packers finished with a 4-2 record in the NFC North this season, and will have to collect another win against a divisional opponent in the wild-card round of the playoffs, when they face the Chicago Bears on Saturday, Jan. 10.

This is a division with talented quarterbacks, including Jordan Love (Packers), Caleb Williams (Bears), Jared Goff (Lions) and J.J. McCarthy (Vikings).

With that, we asked Packers fans the burning question of the week:

Rank the NFC North quarterbacks based on play in 2025

Ryan Dankert: 1. Jordan Love. 2. Caleb Williams, 3. Jared Goff, 4. Malik Willis, 5. J.J. McCarthy

Scott Schneider: 1. Jared Goff - the most accurate passer and best decision-maker with the ball, 2. Jordan Love - accuracy has really improved but I question his leadership and decision-making at times, 3. Caleb Williams - the most physically gifted of all NFC North QB's with the biggest upside, 4. J.J. McCarthy - not an NFL starting caliber QB

Ned Huwatschek: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Dave: Goff, Williams, Love and McCarthy

Rick Frake: 1. Williams, 2. Love, 3. Goff, 4. McCarthy

Mike: 1. Love, 2. Goff, 3. Williams, 4. McCarthy

Daystrom: 1. Love, 2. Williams, 3. Goff, 4. McCarthy

Gerry: Goff, Williams, Love, McCarthy

PeteK: Best – Caleb Williams, then Goff, then Love, then McCarthy at worst

Dennis: Caleb Williams and Jordan Love, Jared Goff, J.J. McCarthy. Williams and Love are about even. Williams is on the rise and I’m not convinced Love will ever be any better than he is now.

Tim: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

Nick: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Steve: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Rory: Williams, Love, Goff, McCarthy

Bob: Love, Goff, Williams and whoever the Vikings put under center

Bob: Williams, Love, Goff, McCarthy

Allyn Michalek: 1) Love, 2) Goff, 3) Williams, 4) McCarthy

David: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

Bob: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Paul Erspamer: 1) Love, 2) Williams, 3) Goff, 4) McCarthy

Phil Uekert: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Paul: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

Ryan: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Jim: Goff, Williams, Love, McCarthy

J. Kaysen: 1. Williams, 2. Love, 3. Goff, 4. McCarthy

JP: 1. Goff, 2. Williams, 3. Love, 4. McCarthy

Michael: Love, Willis, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Jim: Goff, Love and Williams tie, McCarthy

Joel: Love, Goff, Williams, Willis, McCarthy

Jimbo: Goff, Williams, Love, McCarthy

InFact: Williams, Love, Goff, McCarthy

WI Dilettante: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

L Webster: Love, Willis, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Mike Heffling: Willis, Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Ted: Williams, Goff, Love, Willis, McCarthy, Brosmer

Mark: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

JDL: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

Tim Hando: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Erik: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Rob Kreibich: Goff, Williams, Love, McCarthy

Andy: McCarthy, Love, Williams, Goff

Jim: Williams, Love, Goff, McCarthy

Ben: Love is second, only to Malik Willis. Williams and Goff are distant 3, 4. Vikings QB all unranked and don’t deserve to be in the same breath as Love and Willis.

Paul: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

Perry Robinson: Goff, Williams, Love, McCarthy

Greg: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Mark Ellis: Love (proven and still ascending). Williams (ate it, but dude is talented). Goff (still great, but slowing down). Willis (light years better than anyone the Vikings have). Last, whoever the Vikings choose

Pete: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Alan Van Vreede: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Dana: Goff, Williams, Love, McCarthy

Chris: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Drew: Goff, Love, Williams, Willis (Vikings QB next year), McCarthy

Dave: Willis, Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

David: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

ED: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Mike Ryan: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Kevin: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Keith: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Steve: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Tom: Love, Williams, Goff, Willis, McCarthy

Les: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Bob: Goff, Williams, Love, McCarthy

Mark: Love, Williams, Willis (a homer pick there), Goff, McCarthy

Jim: Love, Goff, Williams, Willis, McCarthy

Stephen Norton: Love, Willis, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Park City Scott: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy,

Matt: Williams, Goff, Love, McCarthy

Jim: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Bob: Williams, Love, Goff, McCarthy

Jeff: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Mike: Love, Goff, Williams, Willis, McCarthy

Jim Wendt: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

Mark Marsden: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Steve Snyder: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Delwynn Sherrill: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Allen Wilson: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Ben: Goff, Love, Williams, Brosmer and then McCarthy. I think Love and Goff are a toss-up but Williams is too raw and inconsistent.

Terry Nilles: Goff and Love at the top. Put Willis and Williams right behind them and McCarthy and everyone else a long way back.

B: Goff, Love, Williams, Willis, Brosmer, McCarthy

Michael Izard: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

Dennis Lappen: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Ralph: Love, Williams, Goff and McCarthy. If including backups, I would put Willis ahead of McCarthy.

John Reed: Williams, Love, Willis, Goff, McCarthy

Christopher: Williams, Love, Goff, McCarthy

Mike: Goff, Williams, Love, McCarthy

Dave Campbell: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

Rich: Williams, Willis, Love, Goff, McCarthy

Steve Bradshaw: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Tom Naleid: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

Jack: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

Bill: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Rich: Williams, Goff, Love, McCarthy

Jeff: Goff, Love, Williams, Vikings QBs

Dennis: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

JD: Goff and Williams are very good. Love is up and coming. J.J. is also very good. But if I had my choice to lead the pack right now, I would choose Goff.

Gary: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

David Hansen: Williams, Love, Goff, McCarthy. Might put Willis second overall.

Ben: Love, Goff, Williams, random Vikings QB

Pat: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy. 1-3 are close, 4 is locked in.

Joseph Kromholz: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Derek Larson: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Tom Madsen: Love, Williams, Goff, whoever the Vikings have week in and week out. Love and Williams will be battling it out for the division leadership over the next few season.

Greg Ives: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Gary Statz: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

George: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

Mike: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

Marsha: Williams, Love, Goff, McCarthy. McCarthy could be No. 3 but he was injured too much of the time.

Paul: Williams, Love, Goff, McCarthy

Rich: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Brett: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Erik: Williams, Love, Goff, McCarthy

Robert Komes: Williams, Love, Goff, McCarthy

Marc: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

Mike: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

James Miller: Goff, Williams, Love, McCarthy

Norway: Goff, Williams, Love, McCarthy

Jeff: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Eric: Goff, Love, Williams, whoever the Vikings put under center

Jack: Goff, Williams, Love, McCarthy

Jason: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Ron Raymaker: Goff, Love, Williams, McCarthy

Scott Lucas: Goff, Love, Williams. Minnesota.

Joe: Williams, Love, Goff, McCarthy

Carrollwood Glenn: Love, Goff/Williams (tied), McCarthy

Sweeper: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

James: Love, Williams, Goff, McCarthy

Jesse: Goff, Williams, Love, McCarthy

Ryan Cleary: Williams, Love, Goff, Willis, Wentz, McCarthy, Brosmer

Dick Donovan: Love, Goff, Williams, Willis, guys for Minnesota

Jonathan Backer: Love, Williams, Goff, Willis, McCarthy

Paul Maxon: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Adam: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy. Willis would be No. 3 if he were a starter. Love has never been a volume passer, but he’s an extreme efficiency guy. Seems like he almost never plays badly, always have a chance to win with him – even if he’s not quite at the level where he regularly, singlehandedly takes over a game.

Andy: Williams, Love, Goff, J.J.

MPG: Love, Goff, Williams, McCarthy

Johnny: Love, Goff, Williams, Willis, McCarthy

This article originally appeared on Packers News: Packers fans rank NFC North quarterbacks in the question of the week

Read Entire Article