5 days ago
2
The New York Giants are staring down another offseason defined by seismic decisions, and their head-coaching search was instantly transformed by one of the most shocking firings in recent NFL history.
John Harbaugh is suddenly available after nearly two decades in Baltimore, a stunning move that sent immediate shockwaves through the league and upended the early coaching carousel.
Advertisement
With a proven Super Bowl winner unexpectedly on the open market, the Giants’ next head coach odds have shifted in real time, and Harbaugh’s name now looms large as one of the most intriguing possibilities in New York.
New York Giants next head coach odds
Analyzing the Giants’ next head coach favorites
John Harbaugh
John Harbaugh’s stunning dismissal from the Baltimore Ravens immediately reshapes the NFL coaching carousel, all but guaranteeing him a place atop the short list for teams in need of a new head coach.
A proven winner with five division titles and a Super Bowl championship on his resume, Harbaugh brings instant credibility — a profile few available candidates can match.
Advertisement
Beyond the accolades, he’s a respected motivator and steady leader, fully equipped to handle the pressure, expectations, and relentless spotlight that come with coaching the New York Giants.
In a league where timing often dictates opportunity, patience may have paid off for New York, which could suddenly find itself in a position to make a franchise-altering hire.
Kevin Stefanski
Kevin Stefanski was already rumored to be a leading candidate for this position before his dismissal from the Cleveland Browns.
Now officially available, Stefanski enters the market with a reputation for maximizing the success of limited rosters.
Advertisement
The Giants have pieces to work with, and Stefanski’s offensive mind could help unlock more consistency on that side of the ball. Still, his resume includes just two winning seasons in six years in Cleveland — a fair concern for a franchise searching for a true long-term answer.
Like John Harbaugh, Stefanski’s calm, steady demeanor would serve him well in a market that demands immediate results.
Mike McCarthy
If the New York Giants decide to prioritize experience in their head-coaching search, Mike McCarthy checks every box.
His familiarity with the organization runs deep from years spent across the division with the Dallas Cowboys, and while he wouldn’t headline the splashiest press conference, he would offer something the Giants have lacked: steadiness.
Advertisement
Taking over a young roster, McCarthy would be afforded the runway to rebuild with structure, reset expectations, and establish a professional standard capable of restoring credibility in New York.
Still, this is a market that rarely rewards safe choices, and recent history suggests the obvious answer isn’t always the correct one.
Recent Giants coaching history
It’s been a rough ride for the Giants since the Tom Coughlin days. Ever since he stepped down after the 2015 season, New York’s been searching for the right voice to get this franchise back on track.
Ben McAdoo was the first to take a swing, and things actually started well — 11 wins and a playoff berth in Year 1. But by the next season, the wheels completely fell off, and he was gone before the year even ended.
Advertisement
Then came Pat Shurmur in 2018, and his two-year run wasn’t much better. Nine wins total, and another coaching change followed. Joe Judge got his shot next, and while there were flashes of toughness, the offense never really clicked. He lasted only two seasons, too.
Brian Daboll looked like he might finally be the guy after that surprise playoff run in 2022, even winning Coach of the Year. But things spiraled fast. A messy 2024 and this year’s 2-8 start brought things right back to Square 1.
Now the Giants are hitting reset — again — hoping this next hire can finally stop the carousel and bring some long-term stability to New York.
Odds are correct at the time of publishing and are subject to change.
Not intended for use in MA.
Affiliate Disclosure: Our team of experts has thoroughly researched and handpicked each product that appears on our website. We may receive compensation if you sign up through our links.
This article originally appeared on Covers.com, read the full article here
English (US) ·