Here's why Ty Simpson would transfer to Tennessee football for 2026

6 days ago 2

The idea of Alabama quarterback Ty Simpson transferring to Tennessee football is a legitimate possibility or just wishful thinking by UT fans.

Either way, it’s hard to find a Knoxville sports talk radio show or a UT fan’s social media account that isn’t obsessed with the prospect of him playing for the Vols in 2026.

Numerous media reports have linked Simpson to Tennessee – that is, if he doesn’t declare for the 2026 NFL Draft and if he doesn’t return to Alabama for another season.

Those are two big “ifs.”

Simpson’s sports agent, Peter Webb, told Knox News that the quarterback is weighing his options. He specifically commented on Simpson’s consideration of the NFL draft.

“Still no decisions have been made about Ty declaring for the draft,” Webb told Knox News on Jan. 6. “He is still evaluating everything with his family this week and having lots of calls with close advisors so he can make a very informed decision.”

But why would Simpson, a one-time Heisman Trophy candidate, leave Alabama for rival Tennessee? There’s some logic to it, but also some big hurdles.

Let’s explain why this story has legs.

Ty Simpson would’ve gone to Tennessee if not for this

Simpson was a five-star recruit in the 2022 class out of Martin Westview High in West Tennessee.

He chose Alabama over Tennessee. Nick Saban coaching a perennial national title contender made that a very good option.

But it was understood that Tennessee lost out on landing Simpson because it fired coach Jeremy Pruitt amid an NCAA investigation into a recruiting scandal. Ty's dad, Jason Simpson, was going to be an assistant coach at UT, and Ty was going to follow him there. But then Pruitt was fired.

Instead, Simpson committed to Alabama on Feb. 26, 2021, a month after UT hired coach Josh Heupel. In-person recruiting was restricted by COVID at the time. Heupel was too far behind to make up ground. And UT was facing multi-year probation and the possibility of a bowl ban during Simpson’s playing career.

If Simpson didn’t go into the NFL draft or return to Alabama and instead entered the transfer portal, Tennessee would be a logical choice.

Tennessee fans hope Josh Heupel has a secret plan

The Simpson-to-Tennessee narrative also has gained momentum because UT fans are anxious to land a quarterback, and most of the good ones are already off the board.

As of Jan. 6, 14 of the top 20 quarterbacks in the portal have committed to schools, according to 247Sports rankings. No quarterbacks have visited Tennessee.

Heupel has indicated that UT needs to add a quarterback from the portal to go with George MacIntyre, a former four-star recruit, and Faizon Brandon, a five-star signee.

If UT doesn’t get a quarterback in the portal, Joey Aguilar returning or Simpson transferring seem like viable options. But on the surface, neither seems likely – unless Heupel knows something we don’t know.

Aguilar is attached to the lawsuit filed by Vanderbilt quarterback Diego Pavia against the NCAA in federal court, which challenges the association’s eligibility rules involving former junior college players.

There have been no recent developments in the case. Both parties have made recent filings to the court. But no hearings have been scheduled.

If Simpson is privately planning to enter the portal and go to Tennessee, his camp is not tipping its hand.

Why wouldn’t Ty Simpson declare for NFL draft?

The NFL provides draft grades to underclassmen through its College Advisory Committee.

If Simpson projects as a first-round pick, expect him to declare for the draft. If he gets a second-round grade, he could consider returning to college for his final season of eligibility.

It’s a thin draft class for quarterbacks. Indiana’s Fernando Mendoza, the Heisman Trophy winner, and Oregon’s Dante Moore are projected as top-5 picks.

Many mock drafts done by media outlets slot Simpson as a first-round pick, if he declares for the draft. But there’s also a sense that he could slide because of his late-season struggles.

If Simpson believes he could solidify his first-round stock in the 2027 draft by playing another college season, he may return.

Why wouldn’t Ty Simpson return to Alabama?

Alabama certainly would take Simpson back for one more season. He’s beloved by the Tide and coach Kalen DeBoer. And he earned All-SEC honors in the 2025 season, passing for 3,567 yards, 28 TDs and five interceptions.

Simpson’s return perhaps would nudge backup quarterback Austin Mack toward the portal. And DeBoer would have to tell freshman Keelon Russell, a former five-star recruit, to be patient while waiting for the starting job.

So why would Simpson consider the portal? The only plausible reason is a massive raise in NIL money.

If Simpson were on the transfer market, he would command a very high dollar figure. And teams with deep pockets and quarterback needs would be willing to pay. That’s why Tennessee, Oregon and Miami have been reported as potential suitors.

The question is whether Alabama would be willing to match any offers. After all, Mack and Russell are viable options for the Tide in 2026.

The portal closes on Jan. 16. Expect Simpson to make his NFL draft decision before then. If he returns to college, he’ll be a hot commodity. Until that happens, the NFL still appears to be his most likely destination in 2026.

But rest assured, Tennessee will be watching.

Adam Sparks is the Tennessee football beat reporter. Email adam.sparks@knoxnews.com. X, formerly known as Twitter@AdamSparks. Support strong local journalism by subscribing at knoxnews.com/subscribe.

Get the latest news and insight on SEC football by subscribing to the SEC Unfiltered newsletter, delivered straight to your inbox.

This article originally appeared on Knoxville News Sentinel: Ty Simpson: Could Alabama QB transfer to Tennessee football?

Read Entire Article